Elon Musk’s fight with OpenAI has now landed in federal court, but the filings coming out of San Francisco make his company xAI look desperate. Instead of competing with better products, Musk appears more interested in dragging OpenAI through the courts with claims that read more like posturing than reality.
In its motion to dismiss, OpenAI argues that xAI’s complaint falls apart under scrutiny. The accusations center on former xAI engineers such as Xuechen Li and Jimmy Fraiture, yet nowhere does xAI allege that OpenAI actually received or used any supposed trade secrets. Li never even joined OpenAI. Fraiture deleted code before his first day at OpenAI. That hardly supports the picture Musk is trying to paint.
OpenAI stresses that hiring experienced engineers is not theft. Employees are free to leave jobs they no longer believe in, and California law backs them up. Recruiting talent is normal in tech. If xAI cannot hold onto its own people, the problem is not OpenAI. The problem is Musk.
In its answer and defenses, OpenAI goes even further by calling the lawsuit “groundless” and accusing Musk of using the courts as a tool to scare his own workers. OpenAI points to the fact that many of xAI’s recent departures, including senior executives and lawyers, never even joined OpenAI. They left because of Musk’s chaotic leadership and lack of vision. That is not poaching. That is employees deciding they are done.
One of the more telling examples is the so-called “cloud storage link” that xAI tried to portray as a secret back channel for stolen code. OpenAI says it was nothing more than a recruiting folder with benefits paperwork. Li never had permission to upload files into it. For Musk to twist that into corporate espionage shows how flimsy the complaint really is.
The first hearing is set for November 18, 2025 before Judge Rita F. Lin. If OpenAI succeeds, the case may be thrown out before it ever gets to discovery. If the court allows it to move forward, the battle will only get uglier.
At this point, the filings suggest Musk is not protecting trade secrets. He is trying to spin a narrative to cover for the fact that his employees keep leaving. His lawsuit looks less like a legitimate claim and more like a tantrum from a billionaire who cannot stand losing talent or attention.
Support independent tech journalism
NERDS.xyz is independently owned and operated. If you enjoy my coverage of Linux, AI, hardware, cybersecurity, and tech culture, consider supporting the site on Ko-fi.
Support NERDS.xyz