I’ve always believed in capitalism. Work hard, take risks, earn your keep. It’s not perfect, obviously, but it rewards effort, and for a long time, it felt like the best system we had. If you wanted more, you went out and got it. That’s the deal. The American Dream was obtainable if you worked hard.
But lately, something has been gnawing at me, and sadly, I can’t really shake it.
AI.
Not the hype artificial intelligence that writes your emails or helps you summarize meetings. I’m talking about the kind of AI that is already replacing real jobs. Customer support, junior developers, designers, even parts of journalism. Folks aren’t just worried about it anymore. It’s happening.
And here’s where things start to feel different from past tech waves.
When factories automated, new jobs showed up. When the internet exploded, entire industries were born. There was always a trade. Pain in one area, opportunity in another.
I’m not convinced that trade exists this time. And it’s scary.
AI doesn’t just replace manual labor. It replaces thinking. It replaces creativity. It replaces the kinds of jobs we used to believe were safe because they required a human brain. When that happens at scale, what exactly are millions of people supposed to do?
That’s the question I keep coming back to.
I’m still pro capitalism. I still think markets beat heavy-handed control. But capitalism relies on people having income. People earn money, they spend money, and the system keeps moving. If a huge number of people suddenly can’t find meaningful work, that cycle starts to break down.
You can’t have a consumer economy without consumers.
That’s why ideas like universal basic income, something I used to roll my eyes at, are starting to feel less like a fringe concept and more like something we may be forced to consider. Not because I want a handout culture, but because the alternative could be chaos.
Let’s bring this down to earth for a second. What happens to the average person if this really plays out? The office worker whose tasks get automated. The freelancer who suddenly can’t compete with AI tools. The recent graduate entering a job market that’s shrinking instead of growing. These aren’t abstract ideas. These are real people trying to figure out where they fit.
And it’s not just about income. Work gives people structure. Purpose. Identity. If AI removes that for a large part of the population, we’re not just dealing with an economic shift. We’re dealing with something deeper.
It also raises an uncomfortable question that I don’t hear talked about enough. What happens to things like mortgages, rent, and loans if a meaningful percentage of people simply can’t earn like they used to? Do we just let millions fall behind and lose their homes? Or do we start talking about temporary pauses, restructuring, or something more drastic to prevent a wave of foreclosures and homelessness?
Those are not small questions, and they don’t have easy answers. But pretending they won’t come up doesn’t make sense either.
If AI concentrates wealth even further at the top while hollowing out the middle, what happens next? We’re already seeing tension around inequality, and we’re barely into the AI era. Scale that up, and it’s not hard to imagine things getting ugly.
To be fair, there’s always the argument that new jobs will emerge, just like they always have. And maybe that’s true. Maybe we’ll see entirely new industries built around AI that create opportunities we can’t even imagine yet.
But even if that happens, there’s going to be a gap. A transition period where the old jobs disappear faster than the new ones arrive. And that gap could be painful for a lot of people.
None of this sits comfortably with me. I believe in personal responsibility. I believe people should earn their way. But I also believe in being realistic about what’s coming.
Maybe capitalism adapts. Maybe we land somewhere in the middle. Markets still drive innovation, but there’s some kind of baseline support to keep society stable when traditional jobs aren’t there for everyone.
Or maybe I’m wrong. Maybe AI creates entirely new categories of work we can’t even picture yet, and things balance out like they have before.
I hope that’s how it plays out.
But if it doesn’t, we need to start talking about it now, not after millions of people are already out of work and wondering what happened.
Because for the first time in my life, I’m starting to think the biggest threat to capitalism isn’t socialism.
It might be AI.
Support independent tech journalism
NERDS.xyz is independently owned and operated. If you enjoy my coverage of Linux, AI, hardware, cybersecurity, and tech culture, consider supporting the site on Ko-fi.
Support NERDS.xyz